BioStacks
Jarrow Formulas

CarotenAll

1 Softgel · 60 servings · $0.40/serving

44 / 100Average

Best for

Score Breakdown

Formulation
57
Safety
75
Final score
44/100

Ingredients (7)

Zeaxanthin

100%

Dose

2 mg

Target

2–4 mg

Form

Lutein

100%

Dose

10 mg

Target

10–20 mg

Form

Alpha-Carotene

100%

Dose

500 mcg

Target

0–0 mcg

Form

Lycopene

100%

Dose

10 mg

Target

10–30 mg

Form

Vitamin A

86%

Dose

600 mcg RAE

Target

700–1500 mcg

Form

Budget

Other Ingredients (7)

Caramel ColorColor

Class III and IV caramel colors contain 4-methylimidazole (4-MEI), classified by IARC as Group 2B (possibly carcinogenic to humans) in 2011 (Monograph Vol. 101). California Prop 65 lists 4-MEI as a known carcinogen; products delivering >29 mcg/day require a cancer warning label. NTP TR-535 (2007) found 4-MEI caused lung tumors in mice. Major cola brands (Coca-Cola, Pepsi) voluntarily reformulated 2012-2014 to reduce 4-MEI below California thresholds. Because labels never specify Class I (sugar + heat only, safer) vs Class III/IV (ammonia-process, contains 4-MEI), consumers cannot verify which they're consuming. Combined with the additive's purely cosmetic purpose, the risk:benefit ratio is unfavorable for any supplement.

CarobFlavor

Roasted powder from carob tree pods, used as a caffeine-free chocolate/cocoa substitute for flavor and brown color

GelatinCapsule

Protein derived from collagen, used in traditional capsule shells

GlycerinHumectant

Sweet-tasting liquid used in soft capsules and liquids

Vegetable OilCarrier

Edible oils used as carriers in softgels and as processing aids

Sunflower Seed OilCarrier

Common vegetable oil from sunflower seeds used as a carrier in softgels for fat-soluble nutrients

Purified WaterSolvent

Water meeting USP specifications used as solvent/vehicle in gummies and liquids

Track this supplement in your stack

Get personalized insights, interactions, and coverage recommendations.

Get Started Free

Sources & Scoring

Nutrient data (RDA, UL, and safety thresholds) sourced from: NIH Office of Dietary Supplements and National Academies Dietary Reference Intakes (DRI).

This is not medical advice. Consult a healthcare provider before making changes to your supplement routine.

The score analyzes what's on the label: ingredient doses vs. clinical ranges, chemical forms, evidence levels, and known interactions. It does not verify label accuracy or test for contaminants — for that, look for third-party certifications like USP or NSF.