Every active here is dosed below the amount studied to work. See how each one compares in the breakdown below.
A combination of 5 label ingredients.
Label lists Papain (2 mg). Benefit information is limited.
Breaks down starch during digestion; extra amylase has uncertain benefits for otherwise healthy people.
Amylase
50 mgUnit not recognized — not scored
Bromelain
7 mgUnit not recognized — not scored
MaltodextrinBinder
Spikes blood sugar faster than table sugar (glycemic index 85–105). Research links it to gut bacteria changes that may promote intestinal inflammation (Nickerson et al. 2015). Used as a cheap filler — adds nothing beneficial.
XylitolSweetener
A FODMAP sugar alcohol that can cause GI distress (bloating, gas, diarrhea) at moderate doses (>10-20g/day), though supplement amounts are typically small. Extremely toxic to dogs — households with pets should store securely.
Magnesium StearateLubricant
A salt of stearic acid used as a lubricant in tablet and capsule production
Natural FlavorsFlavor
Broad regulatory category of flavor constituents derived from natural sources. Composition is proprietary and not disclosed — 'Natural Flavors' can include several hundred different compounds depending on the target flavor profile, including hexane-extracted constituents and proprietary carrier solvents. 'Natural' is a regulatory definition (21 CFR §101.22), not a safety guarantee.
Silicon DioxideAnti-caking
Fine silica powder used to prevent clumping
Microcrystalline CelluloseBinder
Plant-derived cellulose used as a binder and filler in supplements
Citric AcidAcidulant
Natural acid derived from citrus fruits
On the label
Take 1 chewable tablet daily.
$45.12
$0.50 / serving
Pricier than 99% of 10 papaya enzyme supplements

American Health
Chewable Papaya Enzyme with Chlorophyll, 250 Chewable Tablets
🍏 for Digestion

Carlyle
Ultimate Papaya Enzyme Plus
🍏 for Digestion

Country Life
Natural Tropical Papaya
🍏 for Digestion

NOW
Chewable Papaya Enzymes
🍏 for Digestion

American Health
Chewable Super Papaya Enzyme Plus
🍏 for Digestion
Sources & Scoring
Nutrient data (RDA, UL, and safety thresholds) sourced from the NIH Office of Dietary Supplements and the National Academies Dietary Reference Intakes (DRI).
This is not medical advice. Consult a healthcare provider before making changes to your supplement routine.
The score analyzes what's on the label: ingredient doses vs. studied ranges, chemical forms, evidence levels, and known interactions. It does not verify label accuracy or test for contaminants — for that, look for third-party certifications like USP or NSF.
Not medical advice. Consult your healthcare professional.